✨This article is proudly brought to you in partnership with the
Cedar Key Historical Society and Museum. ✨

In this inaugural installment of oral histories, listeners experience Cedar Key history not from a textbook, but straight from a true local in his own words. Drawn from a rare 1983 archival cassette recording, the episode features past society historian Charles C. Fishburne interviewing Captain John Milton McCain—known locally as Milton—who was born in 1908 and became the very first participant in the society's oral history program.

Hearing Captain McCain’s unmistakable cadence, dry humor, and unscripted storytelling brings old Florida vividly to life. Rather than dry dates and statistics, you get the authentic voice of a man who lived it—from joking that "they came in here with two cocked guns, walkin' backwards!" when asked how his family arrived, to reflecting on how much simpler and more content life felt in the old days.

Homesteading and Early Cedar Key Family Roots

Captain McCain’s story begins with his family’s arrival in the Cedar Keys in 1876. His grandfather took out a homestead west of Shell Mound before a severe storm wiped them out in 1884. The family later relocated to Turtle Creek in Gulf Hammock—where Milton was born on April 30, 1908—clearing five acres and building log houses over seven years to prove up their 160-acre claims.

Eventually, they moved onto the islands, where Milton's father and uncle ran a fish business for 16 years. When the business went broke, Milton and his father took to the water, living aboard a boat for a decade and rambling everywhere from Key West to Mexico.

A Booming Frontier of Timber, Fiber, and Commercial Fishing

Before Cedar Key became a quiet island retreat, it was an industrial and commercial powerhouse. McCain recalls an era without sewers, drawing shallow water from five-foot wells. Key industries included:

  • Lumber and Pencil Mills: Massive cypress, pine, and red cedar operations dominated the area. McCain vividly remembers the "farewell whistle" at the Tilman mill in Lukens—a tradition where workers tied down the boiler whistle on a mill's final day, letting it shriek until the steam ran completely out. He also recalls seeing the wrecks of historic tow steamboats like the Helen Denham and the Eagle Pencil.

  • The Cedar Key Fiber Factory: Around 1910, a fiber factory established by Dr. Andrews grew to employ roughly 100 local workers.

  • Commercial Fishing & The "Mullet Hearse": Fish were so abundant that on his very first day fishing with hook and line, McCain’s three-man crew caught 3,000 pounds of kingfish in just an hour and a half. Three trains a day served the town until 1927, including a dedicated seafood run affectionately nicknamed the "Mullet Hearse," which hauled out an average of 50,000 pounds of fish daily.

Greek Spongers, Bootleggers, and Changing Shorelines

McCain’s memories capture the colorful characters and shifting coastal landscapes of early 20th-century Cedar Key:

  • The Tarpon Springs Sponge Fleet: Although based in Tarpon Springs, Greek sponge divers frequented the rich sponge beds 80 miles west of Cedar Key on three-month expeditions. McCain watched them transition from rowing double-ended boats to using transom sterns, and noted how they stored their harvests in local dockside warehouses before sailing south.

  • Saturday Night "Let 'Em Go": Workers from surrounding mill towns like Sumner and Lukens rode the train into Cedar Key on Saturday nights to gamble and drink. Even after Levy County went dry, McCain notes that bootleg whiskey was openly peddled right on the streets.

  • A Shrinking Coastline: Having spent his life on the Gulf, McCain observed dramatic coastal erosion. He recalls when the beach was 150 yards wider and a prominent sand spit stretched nearly to Piney Point, dotted with small trees—and how an old 1878 mill boiler that once sat 10 feet above sea level had become submerged at high tide.

Ending just as the interview pauses for a sharp break, this first installment of a two-part series preserves not just local history, but the spirit, wit, and authentic voice of a Cedar Key native sharing his life story firsthand. Subscribe to the Cedar Key Historical Society and Museum on YouTube so you don't miss Part Two!

Learn the History of Cedar Key From the Source

Planning a trip to Cedar Key? Before you cross the bridges onto the island, be sure to follow the Cedar Key Historical Society and Museum’s new podcast, "History from Behind the Curtain," on YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9bhQrAQYqg). You can even queue up an episode and listen in your car as you make the scenic drive to Cedar Key! You can read Mr. Fishburne’s book, “Cedar Key in the 19th Century” to learn more of the fascinating history that Mr. Milton McCain was interviewed for. This book was a 2026 Cedar Key Book Club selection. It can be purchased at the Cedar Key Historical Society.

I use Gemini, an Ai by Google, to help me write and gather information.